AI vs. Human Agents: What Works Best for Car Dealerships?

If you had to book a service appointment for your car right now, would you rather:

Wait on hold for 15 minutes to talk to a human, hoping they get your appointment right…
Leave a message and wait for a call back…
Get instant, 24/7 access to an AI assistant that schedules it in seconds?

We asked professionals in several automotive-related LinkedIn groups to find out how they prefer to schedule their car repairs and maintenance. The answers showed a strong mix of those who liked the personal touch of talking to someone and those who preferred using a digital platform and AI.

For years, dealerships have been struggling with staffing shortages, training and retention cost, overloaded service desks, and frustrated customers stuck on hold or leaving messages that are often not returned. But now, AI-powered agents are flipping the game on its head. And if you’re not paying attention, your dealership might just get left behind.

According to the 2024 NADA Workforce Study, turnover in dealership service departments remains alarmingly high — 39% for service advisors. These roles are among the most difficult to hire, train, and retain due to:

Long hours and burnout
High training costs
Increasing customer service demands

The Number One Reason AI is Transforming Service Departments

Service departments should be a profit center for every dealership. If customers can’t get their cars serviced easily, they will go somewhere else.

That’s why AI-powered assistants are becoming the go-to solution for appointment booking and service inquiries.

‍

AI Agents in Appointment Booking

AI agents, powered by advanced algorithms and natural language processing, can handle appointment bookings autonomously. These systems are designed to understand customer inquiries, check availability, and schedule appointments without human intervention

AI Advantage: Why Dealerships are Making the Shift

24/7, Instant Booking: AI never sleeps, never takes breaks, and never puts customers on hold. A study found that 92% of service teams using AI report to lower operational costs (Salesforce).
Slashes No-Shows by 40%: AI doesn’t just book appointments—it reminds customers, reducing last-minute cancellations (Convin.ai).
100% Call Coverage: AI ensures every single customer is served, eliminating missed calls and overwhelmed staff
(11x More Cost-Effective: AI outperforms human teams in lead management and appointment scheduling (Patagon.ai).

AI Advantage by the Numbers:

92% of service teams using AI report reduced operational costs
(Salesforce, 2022 State of Service Report)
AI reduces no-shows by up to 40% through timely and automated reminders
(Convin.ai, 2023)
100% call coverage: Every lead and customer inquiry is answered, even after hours.
11x more cost-effective than human staff for appointment scheduling and lead routing
(Patagon.ai, 2023)

But What About Human Agents?

AI is fast, scalable, and always available — but there are moments when customers need more than automation.

That’s why the smartest solution isn’t replacing human agents — it’s enhancing their role.

At 11Sight, AI agents act as the first point of contact, handling routine tasks like appointment scheduling and service inquiries instantly. But when a customer needs clarification, has a complex request, or simply prefers a human touch, the AI can escalate the conversation in real time — seamlessly transitioning the customer to a live service advisor via video or audio call, with live context.

‍

AI isn’t replacing human agents—it’s making them ten times more effective.

Imagine if…

Your service team never had to answer another repetitive phone call.
Every service appointment was booked flawlessly and instantly.
Your dealership made more money with less staff stress.

‍

That’s the power of AI.

‍

The future of car dealership service is here. The question is—are you in, or are you getting left behind?

Go Back